Perhaps the most immoral of all is the injunction to love your enemies. That I will not do. I know who my enemies are. At the moment, the most deadly ones are Islamist theocrats with a homicidal and genocidal agenda. I’m not going to love them, you go love them if you want. Don’t love them on my behalf, I’ll get on with killing them, destroying them, erasing them and you can love them. But the idea that you ought to love them is not a moral idea at all, it’s a wicked idea, and I hope it doesn’t take hold… What a disgusting order, to love those people! Destroy them.
– Christopher Hitchens
This is where the difference between Christianity and mere Secular Christendom shines forth. The Christian says wholeheartedly “we MUST love our enemies! The Lord Jesus loved us when we were his enemies, and he commands us to do likewise!” The secularist who has merely inherited the culture of Christian values finds this infuriating and intolerable.
As Islam becomes a primary issue in elections around the world, we need to be reminded that secularism is impotent to address the problem of evil. Both the atheist-left and the atheist-right can offer no solution. A secular society that has inherited Christian values will be much better off than a society without them. But it is not sustainable. When attacked by true evil, the impulse of Secular Christendom is simply to return fire. Only true Christianity gives a basis for facing the evil in the world, addressing it with wisdom and force if necessary, and yet remaining determined to love the people who are doing that evil.
Our society does not primarily need more “freedom” (the right) or more “equality” (the left). It needs more of Christ.